
The finale is finally here dear readers.
It has been one roller coaster season, don't you think? And as much as the judges touted us last year with the phrase "the most talented group in Top 12 history", I think this season proved they had no clue what they were talking about. Looking at the Top 13 this season, in the beginning, you really could not tell who would go on to the finale (with a couple of exceptions). It was that close and it was anyone's game. Out of all of them in the beginning, I could have seen Adam in the finale, but Kris? No freakin' way. He seemed to be one of those contestants the producers let in to fill the gaps. But week after week, Kris proved he was no space filler. He has been consistently just as original as Adam, and the only edge I will give Adam is his personality.

After last night's performances, I have to admit, I have no idea who to pick as the winner. They both had ups and downs last night, and though I think the producers were a bit biased towards Adam (Come on! "No Boundaries" was tailor made for Adam, and played to his strengths, not Kris'. It was obvious there was no way Kris could hit the kind of notes that song called for. A bit unfair if you ask me.), I don't think it made much difference to the audience in the end. I checked several sites this morning that had "fan polls" on who's taking the Idol crown tonight. I can truthfully say they were split down the middle, with some polls having Adam win, and some Kris. ALL polls, however, had a very small percentage of difference in the votes. This really is going to be a very close finish, reminiscent of the Ruben/Clay finale in season two.
Last night, Clive Davis' song choice was replaced by Simon Fuller's(creator/producer of American Idol) song choice. I'm not sure why this had to change, but I would assume it's because of all the other changes that happened with Idol this season. I thought he chose good songs for the contestants, though I think one did better than the other in performing it. They kept the "Contestant's Choice", and both contestants picked smart performances from the season. Finally, I'm not sure why they got rid of the "Song Writing" contest they had last year. I thought that was a great idea, because not only did it give the contestants a choice of what their winning song would be, but it also gave them more control; they could pick a song that suited their style/voice. Hence why I think the producers were dirty handed in going back to the one song sung by both contestants idea. I don't think it mattered in the end. A bad song is a bad song, and I really didn't like the song for either of them. (Sorry Kara, this isn't an award winning song)
I've talked waaay too much already, when I know what you guys really want is for me to get to the meat of the blog; the review itself. Don't you guys want to prolong this blog? Remember, after this final blog, the very one you're reading, you may not be able to read my wise words until next January! (it's like waiting for the next season of Lost to start!)
Okay, fine.
And now, for the last time, we get to the reviews. We begin with a man who brought glam rock back, namely:
1. ADAM LAMBERT –
CONTESTANT’S CHOICE - sung "Mad World" –You have to give Adam props; this was one of his best performances this season, and he picked the perfect song to sing in the finale. I found this haunting, and if it's possible, I found it to be a better performance than his original. Simon was right, when he called it bit too theatrical, but I may need to disagree. Adam IS theatrical, therefore it was exactly what I expected. It shows me the kind of show Adam would put on in a concert. His voice was controlled and on pitch. He did no unnecessary screeching, so the song left me eerily wanting more. I think the theatrics outweighed the actual singing however. He sung it well, but I think the whole production is what was concentrated on. Randy called it right when he called it "Twilight". He was right, because the way that Adam was dressed, plus the fog machine, him descending from the stairs...it was very vampiric and gothic. All in all, I enjoyed Adam's performance very much, though I attribute it more because of the show than the vocals.
SIMON FULLER’S CHOICE - sung "Change Is Gonna Come" – With this song, Adam not only took full creative control, but he made it sound like a new song. This is one of my favorite R&B songs, and the original Sam Cooke version is gold. Adam made this song new again, without making it sound over done. This song has been done to death on Idol auditions, but for once, it did not make me feel like fast-forwarding. His voice was so pitch perfect, even a few high notes finally sounded like actual notes and not screeches. This song proved to me what an extraordinary artist Adam can be, and showed his range. This guy could do glam rock, classic rock, and soul all in the same show! What I really enjoyed is the heartfelt way he sang the lyrics, because not only did he restrain the theatrics, he made you believe in the song. Well done, Adam.
WINNING SONG - sung "No Boundaries" – Can I just say again, at first impression, I don't like this song. I think the song is corny, and not quite as good as David Cook's winning song, "Time of my Life". But here's my problem with it; Adam sung it perfectly. I mean, it was as if the song was written for him. And that, my readers, is my problem with it. I believe it was. Did you hear some of the notes that Adam hit during his performance? There is no way Kris could even come close to hitting those notes. So I will not take away from Adam's performance, because if I'm going to be honest (as Simon says), then this was a brilliant performance by Adam. I can hear it on the radio now. So there is literally nothing bad I can say about Adam's performance of this song. My only gripe is that Kris should have been given a different "winning song", more suited to his strengths. They did that last year, and I thought it was a great move. Why go back to this format?Overall, I would say Adam won two out of the three performances, which would give him the edge on winning the season. I think Adam has the charisma and showmanship to be a star, and all three performances proved that he deserved to be in the finale. Consistently, though, if we're talking season wide, he and Kris are even.
2. KRIS ALLEN –
CONTESTANT’S CHOICE - sung "Ain't No Sunshine" – Wow. All I can say is wow. This was, by far, Kris' best performance the whole season. He made a perfect choice, because this was incredible enough the first time around. Last night, he outdid himself. Each lyric was sung with such passion and sincerity, it made even the straightest man swoon. Kara was right when she said that Kris has a way of connecting to the audience that is so compelling, he not only draws you in, but makes you think he's singing only to you. It was subtle and graceful; a perfect performance for the type of artist Kris is (and will be). Simon was right on the money when he said first round goes to Kris. While Adam's performance was good, it relied too heavy on the theatrics, while Kris' performance relied only on his piano and voice. In the end, it made for a better performance over all.
SIMON FULLER’S CHOICE - sung "What's Going On?" – Great song choice, and great rendition. I've heard this song done many times over the years, and beside the original, my favorite rendition has to be Cyndi Lauper's version this song. (who, coincidentally, is one of the guest performers tonight in the results finale...yay!...but I digress). Kris' version was indeed different, and the way he sung it made you believe the lyrics. It's hard for an artist to make an old song relevant, but Kris accomplished this perfectly. The way he inflected the lyrics made the song connect to the audience and made it relevant in today's modern turmoils. I like the fact that Kris completely broke the song down, and simplified it to a degree that it felt intimate. However, that being said, I still need to give the edge in this round to Adam. While Kris did give a splendid performance, Adam simply out sang him on his song. Maybe it was the song choice, but this round goes to Adam, not Kris.
WINNING SONG - sung "No Boundaries" – I don't know what else I can say about this song that I haven't already said. I hate it right now, but maybe I will grow to like after a few listens. One thing is for sure, Kris did a very poor job with this. It was so obvious this song was so out of his realm and genre. I am crying foul, because this was a song that could not have been more tailor made for Adam. Kris needed a completely different type of song, and I find it a bit unfair he was forced to sing the same song. Even if Kris wins, I just cannot see how his version of this song could possibly have a chance on the airwaves. It will be on the air the equivalent of the time Taylor Hick's winning song was on the radio; ZERO air time. Does anyone even remember what Taylor's (the Idol winner everyone wants to forget) winning song was called? No one? That's my point. Unmemorable. (It was called "Do I make you proud?", by the way). The notes were set way to high for Kris to reach, so he was at a disadvantage from the get go. Luckily, the judges didn't concentrate on the bad performance in their comments afterwards, but chose to sing Kris' praises for the entire season. And that should be what both he AND Adam should be judged on, and not one bad performance. Based on the season, and not this performance, Kris has a very good chance at taking the crown.In summing up Kris' performances, I would say over all, Adam took two out of the three rounds, but with extreme bias from the producers. But I can already tell that Kris would make the type of album I would buy. I love the whole acoustic rock vibe he has. Adam's glam rock vibe is cool, and probably would be more mainstream, but that's not to say Kris wouldn't do well either. There is enough of an audience for both.
The Winner Is...: I will say now, ever since I started doing this review blog, it's the first time I'm stumped. Apparently so are the fans, because as I mentioned in the beginning, most polls I've seen have one or the other winning by a very very small margin. I can't call a winner, but if I need to go with a PERSONAL choice, I would want Kris to win. And that's not to say that Adam is bad. In fact I think Adam's career would benefit from not winning. (see Daughtry)

Tonight, I'm more excited for the finale, not only because my favorite artist of all time is going to perform (Cyndi Lauper!), but we have many other guest performers as well, one of which is Jason Mraz. (I'm calling it now; I predict a duet with Kris).
What did you guys think of the entire season? Are you satisfied with the final two? What did you think of last night's performances? Do you hate the winning song as much as I do? Remember, this is your FINAL time to comment! No more blogs until January! This very blog you're reading is like MY Season Finale!! No blogs until January! Perhaps if I get enough readers to urge me to write about a different show you can have more of me?
Alas, my friends, it's been a great journey this season.
Thanks as always to all my readers, for joining me week to week. I welcome and thank my new readers too!
So until we hear Ryan say “THIS…is American Idol!” next January, I bid you all farewell!













