American Idol – The Season Nine Finale

The time has finally come for us to say goodbye.

Not only is it time to say goodbye to my blog for another year, but this time, we say goodbye to Simon forever. (at least on American Idol). Will the show be the same? I think I can speak for most people when I say, no it won't. I have to say honestly, I don't know if I will be as invested in the show as I was in the past without the presence of Simon, whose truthful, yet brutal honesty always offset the sometimes "playing to the crowd" judges. Whoever they get, has some pretty big shoes to fill, and it would be a travesty if Idol decided to get a copy cat "Simon". If they just get a British dude, who is "brutally honest" and "mean", then for me, Idol has officially "jumped the shark", if reality TV can actually do that. It would be when then added Oliver to The Brady Bunch. Ugh.



Anyway, over all I think Lee and Crystal did pretty well, though I think that nerves suddenly came back to haunt all of Lee's performances. For me, he was off in all three performances, and I couldn't put my finger on it till the end. Maybe it was the new arena or the bigger audience, but he was definitely not as comfortable as he was last week. Crystal was more comfortable than he was, but I don't think it was an issue in the end. Both pulled off great performances and it will be really tough to decide a winner. I thought both their contestant choice songs were good choices, but I have to question the producer's choices. I didn't think "Everybody Hurts" fit Lee very well, and though she did a fantastic job with it, "Black Velvet" was too predictable for Crystal. I know, I'm probably in the minority here, but read the disclaimer text up above where the "Take It Or Leave It" title is; my opinion is always right. So there.

Lastly, the "winning song" this year apparently can be a song already released, as Lee's winning song is "Beautiful Day". I'm not sure if "Up to the Mountain" was a pre-released song or not, but in all they both did well. However, I think Crystal performed hers much better than Lee.

But we'll get to my take soon enough.So shall we get to the final individual performance reviews? I know that's what you want from me, so let's get to it immediately.

CONTESTANT'S CHOICE ROUND:

1. LEE DEWYZE – sung “The Boxer” - This was the perfect song choice for Lee, and something that suited him to a tee. Quite possibly one of his best performances all season, this song made Lee a star in my eyes, and he was wise to re-perform this song at this stage in the competition. The first time I saw Lee perform this, it was back when he was just sort of getting comfortable on stage. There was still a lingering nervousness that took a little bit away from the performance, but not this time. Lee was relaxed and at ease, which made for a more laid back performance. I'm not sure what the judges meant when they said they wanted him to rock it out. You don't need to "rock out" every song to be good. Lee hit every note and emotionally connected to the song more than he did the first time around. Over all, a great start to the night, and a good song choice for Lee.

2. CRYSTAL BOWERSOX – sung “Me and Bobby McGee” - Wonderful the first time around, even better the second time around. Something about Crystal singing this song makes you happy. Not only did this up tempo tune make me smile, but her performance was even better than the first time she performed it. The judges all praised Crystal and I have to agree she deserved all the accolades that were thrown upon her. Whenever it's just Crystal and her guitar, it becomes almost a one on one concert, as if she is singing to you alone. That's why I probably liked her next performance less than the other two; Crystal sans her guitar is awkward. I will say the same about Lee, since I think the guitar is now synonymous with both of them.

PRODUCER'S CHOICE ROUND:

3. LEE DEWYZE – sung “Everybody Hurts” - This was not as good a choice as the judges would lead you to believe. I don't think this song suited Lee's voice very well. Michael Stipe's (lead singer for R.E.M., the original artist for the song) voice is distinctive, and does not come close to Lee's gravely rocker voice. It's not surprising that he struggled with the song at different points. The beginning was especially "rough", as Randy would say, as Lee went off a bit pitchy several times. I will refrain on commenting on the choir showing up again, since it really didn't help make Lee's performance any better. On the whole, the performance was not a bad one, but you can tell Lee was struggling and I blame the producers for giving him a song that really wasn't suited to him. I don't think it was the right type of song for Lee's style, and as a matter of song choices, Crystal got the better choice, though not by much.

4. CRYSTAL BOWERSOX – sung “Black Velvet" - This song was a better song choice than the song chosen for Lee, however, it was a bit predictable. I don't think Crystal is the type of singer suited to the grittiness of "Black Velvet". But, given what she had, she did make the most of it, ditching her guitar and hitting a note I haven't seen her hit all season. It was like Crystal channeled Siobhan for that moment, and held that note in a mind blowing exclamation point to the entire performance. I was not crazy about the arrangement for the song, as it sort of threw me off in following, Crystal deserves credit for chancing this performance without her trusty guitar. This could have went south very quickly, but she managed to pull off a good performance, despite the producer's wonky song choices.

WINNING SONG ROUND:

5. LEE DEWYZE – sung “Beautiful Day” - Maybe it was all the past horrible "winning songs" of seasons past that finally prompted producers to say. "hey, let's let them re-do an already released song, instead of an original song". I'm not sure what the thought process was in deciding that this year, the contestants were able to choose their version of an already well-known song. This U2 song is one of the better ones in most recent years, and unfortunately, I thought Lee sort of got swallowed up by the arrangement. (Kara agreed with me). As with the producer's song choice, Lee had a rough beginning to the song, and he was struggling to sing over the arrangement at times. Plus, I think his nerves got to him again, because he did not seem as comfortable anymore. The funny thing is, even though it was not a great performance, I still don't think it mattered in the end. Lee's popularity has grown by leaps and bounds in the last few weeks, so though a "meh" performance, he still looks like a winner.

6. CRYSTAL BOWERSOX – sung “Up to the Mountain” - I have to say, I'm actually not sure if this is an original song, or if it's a redone song like Lee's. Whichever it is, Crystal blew this performance out of the park. This harkens back to me saying that I didn't feel like I was watching a contestant, I was watching an already established artist. This is exactly the type of artist that Crystal is going to be, and I can truly say, (as Ellen pointed out as well), there has never been an artist like Crystal on Idol in all of their seasons. Crystal was emotionally invested in every lyric, (as Kara pointed out) showing an intense connection that I feel was lacking in some of Lee's performances last night. If determining the winner was based on the "winning song" performances, than Crystal just took the title this season. Truly a great inspirational song, and an "outstanding" performance, as Simon last words stated.

My Pick to be the WINNER for Season Nine: I've been a Crystal fan from the beginning, but Lee started to grow on me. Do I want Crystal to win? Yes. Very much so. I cannot deny that I want her to win as a big fan. BUT, I am a review blogger, and hence I need to be truthful and though I can state my favorites, I need to be unbiased in my choices. Therefore, even though I desperately want Crystal to win (and she still may), I'm actually going to call it and say that, based upon his immense growing popularity as the "regular guy", rags to riches dude, I say Lee Dewyze gets the American Idol Season Nine winner crown.

Surprised at my final prediction? Yeah, I am too. But like I said, it could still go Crystal's way.

So that's it dear loyal readers. Another season on Idol is gone, and with it goes this blog for another year. (well, until January/February of 2011). Are you going to miss me?
Don't answer that.

Let's hear those comments people! This is the final time you can discuss it! Discuss in the comments below, and take the poll! Who wins it tonight? Lee or Crystal?

Until Season Ten, my readers, just like Simon for this season, I bid you farewell!!

American Idol – Semi-Final - The Top Three Compete

The finale is almost here, dear readers.

Only one more week, and then you don't hear from me again until next year! Can you imagine going that whole time without my words of wisdom?

Last night, Idol had its semi-final round, with Crystal, Casey and Lee leading the pack. I thought over all they did pretty well, except the obvious blatant favoritism they showed Lee. I'm not taking away from Lee's performance, but really, he was the only one a choir came out to. Where's the love for Crystal? What happened? Did Idol all of sudden decide that Crystal is not bankable? I doubt that's the case. What I really think is that they know Crystal is a shoe-in for the finale, and they wanted to make sure the person there with her would be Lee and not Casey.

Regardless, it was a very good night of music, but even I had to admit, the best performances did come from Lee. I thought the contestant song choices were a lot weaker than the judge's choices. The strongest song choice came from Simon, and proves to me that he will be sorely missed next season.

Not to ramble on and on, but you know what we all want to get to, so let's get started with a guy who started off the night with a bad song choice, that being:

1. CASEY JAMES – sung “Okay, It's Alright With Me” - To me, this was too much of an unknown song, and I agree with Kara's assessment 100%; you're in the semi-final, and this is your chance to put yourself in the finale. You do not choose a song that hardly anyone knows, because no matter what you did to change it up, no one will know it. To the general audience, they're just hearing the song, so any differences Casey put on the song were lost. As Simon said, the song had no lasting effect. Out of all the songs performed last night, this is the only one that people will say "oh what was that song Casey sung?", as opposed to actually remembering the title and the performance of a more main stream song. It truly was a very bad song choice, and regardless of whether or not Casey sounded good or not, (which he did), it was a big disappointment. It was a dud song choice, and not very memorable.


2. CRYSTAL BOWERSOX – sung “Come To My Window” - I was NOT happy with the arrangement at all. When I heard this is was Crystal's song choice, I really thought she was going to blow it out of the park. But that musical arrangement was so bad, Crystal wound up fighting to have her vocals keep up. For Crystal, the song choice wasn't bad, just the arrangement. She sounded fantastic, but the musical arrangement threw me off. I was trying to love it, when the love for it should have just come naturally. Still, I'm not surprised Crystal chose a Melissa Ethridge song, because that's the type of music she will excel in. She may not have Melissa's raspy tone, and perhaps that also contributed to the performance, but in the end she did sound like she deserved to be in the finale.

3. LEE DEWYZE – sung “Simple Man” - I will show my musical ignorance right now and say I did not know this Lynard Skynard song. But that being said, I think it fit Lee like a glove. It was a very good song choice for him, because coming from an ignorant musical guy like me, the song sounded like it was his original song. To me, it sounded like I was hearing a cut from Lee's album. Lee has established himself as a forerunner now, because compared to the guy we saw weeks ago, the Lee I saw last night was confidant, emotionally connected. This performance, along with Lee's next performance actually showed me that he can just as easily win it all as much as Crystal. I like Lee's humbleness, and I think that's what drawing me more in as a fan. I will never leave my Crystal, but this boy has surely gained me as fan too

4. CASEY JAMES – *Randy & Kara's Judge's Choice* - sung “Daughters" - Randy & Kara definitely picked a great song choice for Casey. I thought Casey started off a bit shaky, but got comfortable very quickly. The song fit Lee a lot better than his first performance. Kara was right when she said Casey shines when he's showing his vulnerable side, and since this is such a slow, laid back song, it could do nothing but show his vulnerable side. I don't know what Simon was talking about when he said it was a "lazy arrangement". Kara and Randy were right when they said essentially, the song is lazy; lazy as in laid back, methodical in its arrangement and tone. As much as I agree with Simon 98% of the time, there are times like this I truly need to question his choices. Casey sounded best during this performance, and though I don't think it will help in the end, he still established himself as a great artist. I see a very bright future for Casey in country music.

5. CRYSTAL BOWERSOX – *Ellen's Judge's Choice* - sung “Baby, I'm Amazed” - Great job Ellen! For someone who joined the judging panel this year, and her only experience in music is dancing, she made a great song choice for Crystal. Crystal didn't change the song too much (some classics should not be touched), but she instead pushed her voice more than I have ever seen her do. Not only did she perform the song without her trusty guitar (in the semi-final! Quite chancy.), she performed it strongly with just as much comfort. As one of the judges pointed out, this proved to audiences that Crystal isn't a one trick pony. She worked outside her comfort zone, sans guitar and blew the performance away. It was the best range I've heard from Crystal's voice to date. I don't think I need to worry, because with this performance, it's a no brainer Crystal is in the finale.

6. LEE DEWYZE – *Simon's Judge's Choice* - sung “Hallelujah” - Okay, I need to call a little bit of shenanigans on Idol for this performance. I'm not taking away from Lee's performance, because it was fantastic. (not better then Justin Timberlake & Matt Morris's version from Hope for Haiti). But really, a choir coming out, when no one else the whole night had that type production? It was a bit much, and a bit obvious they were playing up Lee's performance with that stunt. I really want to believe it was because they want to assure a Crystal/Lee finale, and not a Crystal/Casey finale, but regardless, it's a bit annoying. That aside, the performance was very good. This was definitely a moment for Lee, but did he "own the entire night" as one of the judges described? Maybe, but the choir at the end helped. I bet you the song would not have had a performance impact it did if the choir had stayed up with the band. Still I think Lee can start practicing for next week.

My Pick(s) to be Eliminated Tonight: If there was ever a doubt, you know what I'm going to say. Out of all the performances last night, it is finally time for Casey James to go home.

That's it guys. One more week, and no more reviews. Are you going to miss me? What did you think about the performances last night? Who had the best? Discuss in the comments below, and take the poll!

One more week left!!

Until our final week next week, my readers, I bid you farewell for now!!

American Idol: Week Twelve; The Top 4 Compete

The only word I came up with to describe last night's performances? Underwhelmed.

It was movie night, and the contestants were to choose songs made famous by a movie they were featured in. Though a concept revisited every season, usually it brings out one or two surprise performances. One that comes to mind for me was last season's performance by Kris Allen. He did "Falling Slowly", and I remember thinking to myself "how could he pick this unknown song for an unknown movie?" - Turns out, it was one of the best performances I've ever seen. Not only did I download his version, I still play it once in a while to this day.

Jamie Foxx is crazy. I'm sorry he just is. I'm not taking anything away from his acting or singing talent, but he has a screw loose somewhere. BUT, he did give solid advice, I have to admit. He's no Harry Connick Jr., (the one mentor who all others should be judged against), but he was better than, let's say Miley Cyrus.

I can honestly see the final two by now, and they are Crystal and Lee. By far they both deserve the "artist" t-shirts that Jamie gave out to the contestants, and if either of them are not in the finale, it would be a travesty. As for last night's performances, I have to agree with the judges, particularly Simon, who pointed out the duets were far better than the solo performances. Something weird was going on last night, because some of the song choices were a bit strange. No one out right stunk, but no one stood out either. (both Lee & Crystal sort of had "okay" performances).

But I guess that's enough of my rambling, I should get to the individual performances, starting with a guy who picked one of the most over played songs on the radio, that being:

1. LEE DEWYZE – sung “Kiss from a Rose” - As Randy says, "this one started out a little rough for me". He went a bit off key a few times during the performance, especially in the beginning. But that wasn't really the issue, because I agree with most of the judges when they said he did nothing different with it. Simon was right, it almost bordered on karaoke, and at this stage in the competition, no one should be sounding like that. I think the arrangement is what threw off Lee the most, because he was out of tune. Really surprised at Lee's performance, because I expected more from him at this stage. At the very least he could have chosen a song that hasn't been played to death on the radio for the last 10+ years. Still despite the mediocre performance, Lee has too much of a following for him to be in danger of going home. The fabulous duet with Crystal also helped. SAFE

2. MICHAEL LYNCHE – sung “Will You Be There?” - What a weird choice. I don't think it fit Michael at all. Randy was right when he said something weird was going on with the song choices. This gospel inspired Michael Jackson song from Free Willy was a very odd choice. Did Michael sing it well? Yes, most definitely. But I just don't think it was the best song choice at this stage to keep you in the competition. Kara pointed out Michael's past performances of "Woman's Work", and how this just wasn't the right fit. I really have to agree, and while this wasn't Michael's best performance, it didn't measure up to his past performances. To me, it's almost like a step backward. I know I've always complained about how Michael bores me, and he should do something different, but gospel? I expected a bit more R&B. Considering who is left in the competition and who my choices are, I need to say Michael is probably in a bit of trouble. IN DANGER


3. DUET - CRYSTAL BOWERSOX & LEE DEWYZE – sung “Falling Slowly” - Thanks to Kris Allen from last season for introducing this song to Idol audiences. Seems like now it being repeated, albeit in duet form. I fell in love with this song when Kris performed it last year, and I have to say, Crystal & Lee pulled off a very beautiful rendition of it. I think Crystal sounded a bit better than Lee, and that's not because I am a Crystal fan. Lee's voice to me struggled to find a foothold in the beginning of the song, but by the time the chorus came around with Crystal, it found its way. I may have to download this version too. Maybe. Great duet.


4. CASEY JAMES – sung “Mrs. Robinson" - This was a great, cool, laid back version of this classic tune, and I have to say I loved it. I disagreed with the judges on how they pointed out it was too safe, and sound alike. I thought Casey's version was intimate, and showed a nice softer side. I do need to point out that his choice was ironic, since the judges have been teasing Kara all season about her infatuation with Casey. I thought Casey did more than a decent job, and it's one of the few times I can personally say I enjoyed. Despite the decent performance, and the strong duet with Michael, I just don't think it was strong enough to stay in the competition. Casey has been in the bottom three before, so considering who is left in the competition, I don't think there's much choice as to where Casey is going to be tonight. IN DANGER


5. CRYSTAL BOWERSOX – sung “I'm All Right” - How awesome is it that Crystal loves Caddyshack?! One of the funniest movies, like ever, and not only does she know it, she picks a song featured in it! If you ever heard the original, it is a very up tempo song, but by slowing it down, Crystal made it sound brand new. In many ways, the judges were right, she did make it better. Crystal makes no excuses, and she played the song brilliantly. Not Crystal's best performance (again, all the solo performances were not as good as the duets), but definitely the type of performance that proves not only does she deserve to wear that "artist" t-shirt, but she should be in the finale. SAFE



6. DUET - MICHAEL LYNCHE & CASEY JAMES – sung “Have you ever Really loved a Woman?” - I loved this song when it first came out. I never really had a thing for Bryan Adam's music, but I did have a few songs here and there. This was one of them. Michael and Casey did a great version, though Casey almost had a huge issue right in the beginning: he forgot the words for a couple of seconds. He rescued himself very quickly and recovered, but the "damage", so to speak, was done; Michael wound up performing better. Casey recovered enough to make the duet a memorable one, but I don't think in any way was it better than (or equal to) Crystal and Lee's duet.

My Bottom TWO Picks: Yes, no more bottom three as of tonight. With only four contestants left, a bottom two is all that can be chosen at this point. And though it's not easy, considering who has been consistent throughout the competition, and who has never been in the bottom, I need to choose the only two that make sense: Casey James and Michael Lynche.

My Pick(s) to be Eliminated Tonight: It could really go either way, but considering how popular Michael still sort of is, I would say it's time Casey James to pack his bags.

So what did you guys think of movie night? Were you surprised at some of the song choices? Were they strange? Did you agree the duets were better than the solo performances? Discuss in the comments below, and take the poll!

Two more weeks left of Idol, my readers!!
Until next week my readers, I bid you farewell for now!!

American Idol - Week Eleven- The Top 5 Compete

I can't believe we're down to the Top Five already. Wow. Does it seem that this season went by pretty quickly to anyone else? I mean, granted, this really hasn't been a great season, but still went by pretty quickly.

Last night was Frank Sinatra night for Idol, and I have to say most of the contestants did a decent job of most of the songs. Although I have to wonder sometimes if the judges hear what I hear. I found myself disagreeing with most of them last night, so I'm starting to believe what they say about how things sound in the theater then on television. Harry Connick Jr was the mentor this week, and I have to say, probably one of the best mentors I've seen on Idol in any of the seasons. I have never seen a mentor get so involved, and generous with his/her time. Not only did he make suggestions to the contestants, but he composed the arrangements! And he could have stopped there, but no, he actually played with the band last night. What a truly amazing guy Connick is, and I have to say past and future mentors need to take note.

It's going to be hard to pick out a bottom three this week, since now we're down to the top five. I actually don't even know if Ryan will even have a bottom three. He may pull the old "two on one side", "two on the other" and ask the fifth contestant to choose a side that is safe. I have no idea, I'll just pick a bottom three this week, based on their performances last night, frequency of appearing in the bottom, and popularity. So let us begin with our youngest contestant, who looked really dapper and cute last night, that being:


1. AARON KELLY – sung “Fly Me to the Moon” - Our little Aaron has grown up! The only thing I kept thinking of when he was singing was how classy he sounded. There was no hint of country, and yet he still made it sound good. I need to disagree with Simon on this one, because I thought Aaron did an amazing job with this Sinatra classic. Granted, I will agree that he did much better last week, however, as one of the judges pointed out, that was a week he was in his element. But even outside his element, Aaron still pulled off a fairly decent version of the song. I like the inflection he put on some of the lyrics, and his vocals were pretty spot on. Despite all this, taking into account that there are only five left, and considering Aaron has shown up in the bottom three before, I have a strange feeling Aaron may be in a bit of trouble. However, just as Kara pointed out, I'm pretty sure he'll be around next week. IN DANGER

2. CASEY JAMES – sung “Blue Skies” - Oh poor poor Casey. This was indeed by far his worst performance, and this is one of the performances I actually agreed with the judges' assessments. He was thrown so far out of his comfort zone, he didn't recover. Not only was the beginning extremely pitchy, it stayed pitchy almost throughout the entire song. Judges pointed out how something was off about his performance, and that he looked awkward and uncomfortable on stage. It seems that without his guitar, Casey seems a bit lost. The whole song just went downhill from the very first note, and considering Casey showed up in the bottom three last week, I don't like his chances this week. Of all the contestants, he is the only one who got the dreaded "worst of the season" comment. This will not bode well for Casey, and he might need to pack his bags tonight. IN DANGER


3. CRYSTAL BOWERSOX – sung “Summer Wind” - One of my favorite Sinatra songs…ever. Seriously, I was ecstatic that my favorite, Crystal, was going to be performing it. I love how Crystal transforms herself week after week. I dug the whole lounge singer vibe she gave the song, and I think she pulled off a decent rendition. She looked absolutely amazing last night though, dare I say gorgeous. And who knew she had that giant flower tattoo on her back?! It was rockin!! It gave her a feel of "classy, but free-spirited". I'm not sure I agree with most of the judges' comments about Crystal's performance, and that's not because she's my pick to win. As a fan of the song, I would have admitted if it sounded bad. But it really didn't. Did it measure up to Crystal's past performances? No, it definitely did not, however, it still ranked good enough. That being said, if I'm going to be fair, and if I am seriously considering all factors, for the first time ever, much as I hate to admit it, Crystal may make a onetime appearance in the bottom three tonight. Why? the last two performances of the night blew the first three out of the water. (yes, even Michael's performance was good) If there has to be a bottom three, Crystal may be one of the three. However, I don't think she is in any danger of actually going home. IN DANGER


4. MICHAEL LYNCHE – sung “The Way You Look Tonight" - Again, one of my favorite Sinatra songs ever. My close friends Jenn & Chris chose this classic as their wedding song, so you can truly understand what a great one this is out of Sinatra's songbook. Michael did a great rendition, keeping the classic recognizable, but yet still adding his own spin to it. You knew it was a Sinatra song being sung by Michael. Personally, I wouldn't praise it as much as all the judges did, but it was definitely better than the first three performances. (sigh, yes, even better than Crystal's). The vocals were still really spot on, as they always are with Michael. And as for Michael always picking ballady slow songs, he gets a pass this week. But I still find myself bored. I am longing to see him do something different at this point. As it stands with last night's performance, welcome to the Top Four, Michael. SAFE


5. LEE DEWYZE – sung “That's Life” - Holy cow, this was by far the best performance of the night. Lee had actual swagger!! He had confidence! It was like watching a whole other artist! It was by far Lee's best performance to date, because his personality finally showed through brilliantly. He added inflection where it was needed, and brought a bravado to every lyric. Truly one of the best renditions of this song I've heard in a long time. (but don't throw paper at me yet, because nothing beats the classic). Lee has grown so much in the last 3 weeks, at this point it's just a waiting game until the finale. Lee, like I told Michael, welcome to the Top Four. SAFE

My Bottom Three Picks: Ugh, this was a very tough week. The only one I'm sure of being in the bottom is Casey, and the other two…who knows, I could be way off. I'll stick with my choices, though I really want to not include Crystal: Casey James, Crystal Bowersox and Aaron Kelly.

My Pick(s) to be Eliminated Tonight: I was wrong about my pick to go home last week, but I was right about who the bottom three were. This week, considering who might be in the bottom three, it is pretty easy to see that Casey James is going to be leaving the competition tonight.

What did you guys think of Sinatra night? Do you think Sinatra's daughters aged well? Were there any outright song disasters for you? I'm not getting many comments this year from you guys. Let me know you're out there! Discuss in the comments below, and take the poll!

Until next week my readers, I bid you farewell for now!!

American Idol: Week Ten; The Top 6 Compete

I was a little thrown last night.

Of all the theme nights I've seen on Idol, I never thought the songs of Shania Twain would make the cut. I mean, granted, I know she's had a successful 15 year career, but really, unless you're a country fan, you maybe heard only her 5-6 most popular hits. Personally, I just don't think her career was long enough or iconic enough to justify dedicating a whole night of performing her songs. But alas, that's what it was last night, and surprisingly, the Top 6 all did pretty well. No one really did horribly, which makes it a tough choice when it comes to who goes home tonight.

I thought Shania was one of the better mentors they've had this season, but come on, who would have been better to guide the contestants on Shania Twain songs, then Shania Twain? The one person that really shone for me last night, is Aaron. Yes, I know, all of you are surprised I didn't say Crystal…who still did well, but Aaron really stood out. They over all did a great job, despite it being country week, which usually ends in disaster in past seasons.
So shall we move onto the individual reviews? Let's begin with someone who doesn't quite fit the country vibe, but managed to rock out Shania. That person being:

1. LEE DEWYZE – sung “You're Still The One” - I liked Lee's performance, but as Randy said, it did start out a bit pitchy. Once he got to the chorus, the song really picked up for me, and you felt Lee's connection to the song. Kara pointed out that he was smiling, which helped showed his emotion. I agree, because when Lee smiles it makes all the difference in his performance. One of the judges pointed out that Lee didn't just do a copycat performance. It sounded like "his" version of the song, and it was just as good as the original. Lee can see the finish line, and he just might be in it. (with Crystal). He doesn't go anywhere this week. SAFE

2. MICHAEL LYNCHE – sung “It Only Hurts When I'm Breathing” - Oh my God, are ballads and slow songs the only songs that Michael knows?! Week after week, it's the same old types of songs over and over again. Of course, he does them extremely well, is well connected to almost every song, and emphasizes the lyrics. But really, another slow song? I was never a big Michael fan, but I started getting on the train when he performed "A Woman's Work". Now I'm officially off the train again, and I'm not getting back on. Why? Because I'm bored. Bored to death with Michael's performances. I get sleepy during his performances. You may argue that his vocals are phenomenal, and I would agree with you. But if you're going to do the same types of songs week to week, then you won't keep people's attention. Because of this, I think he may be in trouble tonight, despite his good performance. IN DANGER

3. CASEY JAMES – sung “Don't” - For the first time since he started, I think I came very close to deciding to download this Casey performance. (I didn't…but came close). I agree with the judges 100%; this was by far Casey's best performance…ever. Not only was it the perfect song choice, he showed a vulnerability I haven't seen before. He didn't over compensate with his guitar, and actually concentrated in the vocals of the song. One of the judges pointed out how it didn't even feel like a Shania song, and I have to agree. It sounded like a song that would be on his album. He made it rock country, and it stood out as one of the better performances of the evening. Still, I think despite an outstanding performance, I think he may wind up in the bottom tonight, because of the fact he was there last week. I don't think in any way he'll be going home, but I think he'll be one of the three. IN DANGER

4. CRYSTAL BOWERSOX – sung “No One Needs To Know" - I find myself agreeing with the judges on this one as well…it wasn't my favorite performance from Crystal. I didn't hate it, and by far, it wasn't a bad performance. It just didn't set with me very well. It was like a piece of candy that you think is going to be really sweet, but turns out to be tart. I admire the fact that Crystal did something different again, and she takes chances. (See Michael? You don't have to do slow songs every single week…take a cue) It's obvious country is not going to be the genre that Crystal would record an album in. But not by a long shot should she be worried. Every artist has an off night, and considering what a ride Crystal has had, this was hers. And might I point out, even on her off night, she still sounded better than past contestants' good nights. No way she goes anywhere this week. SAFE

5. AARON KELLY – sung “You've Got A Way” - Wow, this kid has grown. This was the night of the "best evers", because not only was tonight Casey's best ever performance, but Aaron's as well. It was glaringly obvious this kid was born to sing country, and he was in his element. And how adorable is he saying that he was singing the song to his mom? Kara pointed out how much emotion and depth he showed when singing the song, and I agree. I felt his connection to the song, and the emotion behind it. I think because he was singing to his mom, he felt the emotion more and it came out in his performance. Amazing performance! Normally, I'd have said Aaron would be in trouble tonight, but I think because of this fantastic performance, he's going to be around for at least one more week. SAFE

6. SIOBHAN MAGNUS – sung “Any Man of Mine” - The last 2 weeks I haven’t been blown away by Siobhan like I was when the season started. And though she did much better this week, it still didn't blow me away. she went back to "the scream", and this time I agree with Randy; it really did sound like she was giving birth. It felt forced again, and I think she's starting to rely on it too much. I think she made a good song choice, and I enjoyed the punk/country vibe she placed on the song. But that scream…a bit unnecessary in my opinion. I don't think Shania screamed that note in her song, so it really didn't fit. I think Siobhan has lost some steam over the last few weeks, and even though she regained some this week, I think she may need to worry tonight. IN DANGER

My Bottom Three Picks: How tough is it this week to pick a bottom three?! I think I'm pretty solid with my choices. But though I may be off with one of them (my gut thinks Lee might surprisingly be in the bottom), my choices this week are: Casey James, Siobhan Magnus and Michael Lynche.

My Pick(s) to be Eliminated Tonight: Out of the three I chose, it was easy to pick who would be going home. I think because he has failed (or refused) to do more than slow songs, and really hasn't given us anything different, it's time for Michael Lynche to pack his bags. No save this time, Michael!

So was I right? Was I wrong? With the performances being this good, was I way off in my logic? You guys need to call me out on it! Discuss in the comments below, and take the poll!

Until next week my readers, I bid you farewell for now!!

American Idol - Week Nine - The Top 7 Compete

Okay, it's confession time: I was looking more forward to watching Glee's all Madonna song episode last night than watching Idol. There, I said it.
That aside, I didn't hate this week's crop of songs, but in general, with the exception of maybe Crystal and Lee (who I'm starting to see in the finale), no one really stood out for me. No one else was memorable, and I really didn't see "star quality" in anyone else. My best friend Tom put it best, when he posted "Would Idol just give the friggin' season to Crystal, and be done with it already?" Kidding aside, I'm beginning to agree. Crystal seems to be in a whole other class than the other contestants.

I thought Alicia Keys was a decent "mentor" this week, but I have to question some of the song choices made by the contestants. Really, Siobhan, I understand why you chose the song you did, but being afraid of doing a song, and not having the experience or talent to perform it are 2 different things. Alicia's pointers were valid, but overall I don't think her suggestions could have helped some contestants.

Tonight is a two hour results show, because it's Idol Give Back. Plenty of musical guests on, but I do suggest watching the show about an hour in if you're gonna DVR it, so you can fast forward the musical guests you don't like. At least that's what I do. Heh.

As usual, let's get to the individual performances, starting with this season's eye-candy, that being:

1. CASEY JAMES – sung “Don't Stop” - I think Kara summed up for me what my feelings about Casey are: he's consistently good, but he hasn't been great. He's getting left behind by Lee and Crystal. Though his vocals were pretty good, I think he's making his guitar playing the highlight of his performances, and not his voice. His song choice wasn't really memorable, and as a result, he didn't stick out. Simon called Casey's song choice, and I tend to agree. It was safe, and he didn't really change it up. It sounded almost like the original, and as we've learned on Idol before, copycat performances don't get you very far. I can't believe I'm about to do this, but I think I need to put Casey in the danger zone tonight. IN DANGER

2. LEE DEWYZE – sung “The Boxer” - If I'm going to be honest, I will admit, I knew the song very well, I just never knew the name of it. I always liked this Simon & Garfunkel song, but the title always escaped me. And what a way to find out the title! Simon was 100% right when he said Lee modernized the song, and made it sound fresh and new. It sounded just enough like the original for me to recognize it, but Lee put a great rock vibe to it, and made it sound contemporary. He looked totally confident on stage and throughout his whole performance, I felt he totally connected not only with the song, but the audience as well. Lee has grown so much in the last few weeks that I think I can finally see who is going to be in the finale with Crystal. That's right Lee, it's you. SAFE

3. TIM URBAN – sung “Better Days” - Well, appropriate song choice, since Tim has had "better days" last week. Seems to me though it wasn't terrible, it was definitely a step backward from last week's performance. I could be wrong, but I think Tim went off key a few times, especially in the beginning. It was a bit all over the place for me, and the arrangement was a little weird. Love him or hate him, you have to admit, Tim is one of the more likable hold outs that Idol has had. Hey, he could have been another cocky Sanjaya! Tim takes the judge's comments and suggestions and he runs with it. Even though he has improved immensely over the last 3 weeks, I think last night's performance sort of put him back in the danger zone. Sorry Tim, you might be in trouble. IN DANGER

4. AARON KELLY – sung “I Believe I Can Fly” - Big song Aaron. He pulled it off I think, though it definitely wasn't his best performance. What saved Aaron's performance last night was the second half of the song, which I thought was fantastic. The beginning of the song was "rough", as Randy loves to say, but by the time he got to the middle of the song, his vocals took off. That ending was phenomenal, and you got to give this kid credit for taking on such a big song. It could have gone very badly very quickly, but except for a few stumbles in the beginning, he did a pretty decent job. Aaron is lucky he's cute, because that's what I think will get him through this week. His talent, like Casey's, is getting overshadowed by more experienced performers. I think you might be in the clear this week Aaron, but you need to step it up, or you might be gone next week. SAFE

5. SIOBHAN MAGNUS – sung “When You Believe” - I mentioned it before in the beginning of my blog, and I'll say it again. I understand her reasons for choosing this song. She said she loved the song, and didn't want to be scared of doing it, because of who the artists were. BUT, my issue with that is, just because you like a song, and don't want to be intimidated by the artists who sang it, doesn't mean you have the talent to pull off a good performance of it. Siobhan is good, no question about it, but a Whitney AND Mariah song?! REALLY? Mariah and Whitney alone are what we call "untouchable" artists on Idol, especially if you don't have the talent to give their songs a great performance. Siobhan made a mistake, and she should be thankful her vocals were spot on. It's probably what saved her from being in the bottom three this week. SAFE

6. MICHAEL LYNCHE – sung “Hero” - Yawwwwwn. I'm yawning, so it must mean Michael is performing. Seriously, I know Big Mike has his fans, but must he forever do soft and slow ballads? This was a completely forgettable. YES, as usual his vocals were great. He hit every note and connected with the song. But wow, was I bored. Compared to other performances last night, even Aaron's performance was more exciting. I think Michael has ridden this train as far as it will go. People are starting to see the same old thing from him week after week, and since everyone else is changing their game, Michael is getting left behind. Sorry, Mike, I think you may be in danger tonight. IN DANGER

7. CRYSTAL BOWERSOX – sung “People Get Ready” - Do I really need to review her? Come on, what can I say about Crystal that hasn't been said already. She not only did something different by singing sans instrument (See Michael?), but her performance was so heartfelt, so emotional that it completely blew every other performance out of the water. It was almost appropriate that they ended the night with Crystal, because in a sense, Crystal sort of showed them all "how it's done". Her tearful last note just brought it all home, and brought the performance to a new level. Seriously, not only is she safe, she can pretty much guarantee her finale spot at this point. SAFE

My Bottom Three Picks: I know what you guys are thinking. You're all saying I made some surprising choices for the bottom three this week. Except for Tim, you probably think that both Michael and Casey don't belong there. And heck, you may be right. BUT I was right last week, wasn't I? Makes you think, no? My choices this week: Casey James, Tim Urban and Michael Lynche.

My Pick(s) to be Eliminated Tonight: I want to say right off the bat, I want it to be Tim. I really do. I think he's gone as far as he could go, and it should be Tim going home this week, because the other two are far more talented then he is. But he's not going home yet. I know, I know, but it feels like a "surprising" elimination kind of night. It could go either way, but I'm gonna say of the two remaining, it's Casey James time to finally go home.

What did you guys think this week? Were you bored? Do any of you see finalists at this point? Take the poll below!

Until next week my readers, I bid you farewell for now!!

American Idol: Week Eight; The Top 9 Compete

Did last night's performances leave the King rolling over in his grave?

For the most part, I don't think so. Most of the contestants did a fairly decent job of performing the hits of Elvis. However, at this stage in the competition, is it just me, or should I expect a little more than just "fairly decent jobs" at song performances?
Great job by Adam Lambert as mentor by the way, since something he said to the contestants beforehand struck me. He said, "Who am I to be coaching you, since I'm just starting my career as well?" To me, that showed Adam's humbleness, and showed he was only there to offer his honest suggestions, nothing more.

A note on last week: Boy, I could not have been more off at my bottom three picks! The only one I got right was Andrew, and he didn't go home. I honestly didn't see Michael being up there, but I'm not that surprised. Most of you readers know I never was fully on the Michael train, and I think it comes down to the fact that he bores me. He does the same types of songs week to week. BUT, did he deserve to go home? I would say probably not, but at the same time, I don't think the judges should have used their save already. Seriously, I would put Lee and Casey in front of Michael for talent, and if either of them wind up going home, there is no save to keep them in. And Michael's performance last night yet again left me sleepy. Yes, it was very good, and the vocals were phenomenal, but it didn't excite me at all.

Anyway, let's get to the individual reviews, since that's what most of you want from me anyway. Yeesh, I feel so used. To begin, let's start with the only contestant who has been consistently good from the start, that being:

1. CRYSTAL BOWERSOX – sung “Saved” - She not only put her own spin on it, but it sounded like a song I would hear on the radio today. Granted, one of the judges said this as well, but they couldn't have been more right. I love that she used an electric guitar as opposed to the acoustic she usually uses. This is what I like about Crystal, she constantly changes something week to week, to make her memorable, and her performances fresh. There's no way she's going anywhere for a while. At this point, I see her on the express train to the finale. SAFE

2. ANDREW GARCIA – sung “Hound Dog” - Wow, this was bad. I can totally agree with Simon, who I think is the one that said that in the last few weeks, it's like the coolness has been totally sucked out of Andrew. I really need to agree, because there was nothing redeeming about that performance. The fact that he slowed it down made it worse in my opinion. It was a very bad karaoke version of a classic Elvis tune, and it was sort of all over the place. The whole performance I was thinking, "I can't believe how bad this is, coming from a guy who I thought might have made a comeback recently". Andrew, remember how you were in the bottom three last week? Be prepared to revisit. IN DANGER

3. TIM URBAN – sung “I Can't Help Falling In Love With You” - Oh. My. God. I can't believe I'm about to say this, and please readers, if I'm wrong, call me out on it. Maybe my ears are not what they used to be, because did I just hear a fantastic version of one of my favorite Elvis tunes, by resident comeback kid, Tim Urban? Was that really him? This was one of the most beautiful versions of this song I've heard in a very long time, and the fact that it was sung by Tim, I will never get over. Really? Was it really him? The whole performance came from the heart, and I will say this is the best performance I've seen him do since he first started the competition . This was definitely his "moment", and I don't see the comeback kid going home this week....again!! SAFE

4. LEE DEWYZE – sung “A Little Less Conversation” - I'm starting to like Lee more and more as each week passes. This week's performance I saw him less nervous, more confidant, and even smiling more. (thanks Adam, for telling him that piece of advice) This was a perfect song choice for Lee, but I do understand what Kara was talking about when she said that Lee should have been less "harder" singing the song. Not every song needs to be pelted out in such a gruff manner, and this song could have used a little more vocal finesse. But that is a minor flaw with this otherwise great performance. He'll be around next week. SAFE

5. AARON KELLY – sung “Blue Suede Shoes” - Give Aaron an A for effort. I agreed with Simon when he said the beginning was horrible. When Aaron got to the middle, that's when it started to get good. In all Aaron did a halfway job with this performance. The first half he was pitchy and came off very karaoke and corny. Hear those cheers? Little Aaron has some female fans out there. (and some male ones too, let's not exclude). Tim seems to be the heartthrob this season, but Aaron has his fair share of fans to keep him afloat. I don't think this performance was his swan song home, because I do think he has more talent to show us. But this performance will place him in the bottom this week. IN DANGER

6. SIOBHAN MAGNUS – sung “Suspicious Minds” - Just like Aaron, Siobhan gave a half performance this week. Half was really good, and half was...not so good. I've noticed, as I'm sure many of you have, that Siobhan doesn't do that well when she's singing in her lower register, as the beginning of the song showed. By the time she hit the chorus, we saw the Siobhan we all like. Honestly, I still think it was a bit oversung. Siobhan has too many fans for he to be in danger, so I'm pretty sure she's staying. SAFE

7. MICHAEL LYNCHE – sung “In The Ghetto” - I was boooored. I thought Michael's vocals were spot on, but damn, this made me soooo sleepy. The original wasn't this slow, was it? Because honestly, slowing this song down to a crawl just sort of zoned me out. I found myself getting up for the bathroom, when I should have been riveted to his performance. And all you Michael fans, I'm not showing hate here, because I respect Michael's vocal ability. The guy has a set of pipes equal to the size of his arms. BUT, he needs to start getting me excited, and not put me to sleep. Since he got the save last week, I sincerely don't think he'll be going home this week. SAFE

8. KATIE STEVENS – sung “Baby, What Do You Want Me To Do?” - Strange song choice, but that's only on me. I never heard of this Elvis tune, but Katie did a pretty decent job of it. Her vocals were great, but what stood out for me most is her confidence level. The girl I saw weeks ago wasn't on stage now. Gone were her nerves, and her vocal range shown through on each lyric. Simon thought it was a bit screechy, and I can see parts where he would be right, but for me, most of it was really good. However, like last week, I think all these good performances are sort of "too little, too late" for Katie. There are much more talented contestants who have now surpassed her, so I don't think she's safe, despite a great performance. IN DANGER

9. CASEY JAMES – sung “Lawdy Miss Clawdy” - Yet another Elvis song I've never heard of, but Casey made it sound like it belonged on his album. I can see Casey making it big on the country charts. I'm talking Carrie Underwood big. Simon said because of his song choice, the performance was forgettable. In part, I agree, but Casey made the song his own, and made it sound like it was his song. Honestly, if I heard this on the radio, I wouldn't say, "Hey, who redid that Elvis song?", I would think it was his song. Casey is not going anywhere this week either. SAFE

My Bottom Three Picks: You guys know I'm right not to include Tim in this bottom three right? Come on, give it up for the guy. Give him kudos, because that really was one of the better performances from last night. So who's in danger this week? My choices: Andrew Garcia, Aaron Kelly and Katie Stevens.

My Pick(s) to be Eliminated Tonight: No one went home last week, so that means that of my bottom three picks, only one of them is safe, and the other two go home. Based on performances, popularity, and consistency, I would need to say that it's Andrew Garcia and Katie Stevens time to finally go home. Michael gets a stay of execution, as does Aaron.

What did you guys think? Was I totally wrong about Tim? Did he have one of the best performances? Who had the worst? Take the poll below!

Until next week my readers, I bid you farewell for now!!